25 Restaurants in NYC with the MOST Reviews: Yelp’s Top Picks Revealed

New York City, a culinary paradise where every street corner offers a mouth-watering experience.

Hungry for crowd-pleasers? This article compiles 25 of the most talked-about restaurants in NYC, based on Yelp reviews.

Explore a variety of flavors, ranging from comfort foods to exquisite menu items you’ve been craving. So, get ready to indulge in the ultimate guide to NYC’s most reviewed eateries!

1. Katz’s Delicatessen

Katz’s Delicatessen, a culinary landmark in New York City, stands out for its rich history and delectable offerings.

Katz's Delicatessen

With over 15,352 reviews on Yelp, it holds an impressive 4.0-star rating, reflecting its popularity and quality.

Located at 205 E Houston St, New York, NY 10002, Katz’s is renowned for its traditional Jewish deli cuisine, specializing in pastrami and brisket sandwiches, along with other “kosher-style” meals.

Don’t just take our word for it, check out this review, highlighting the unique experience:

Katz Delicatessen in New York City is an iconic stop for any deli enthusiast. The moment you step in, you’re greeted by the bustling ambiance, a testament to its popularity and the quality it offers. … Each bite is a delightful experience, rich in flavor and tradition.

2. Joe’s Shanghai

Joe’s Shanghai, a bustling eatery known for its authentic Shanghainese cuisine, stands out in New York’s culinary landscape. With a staggering 7,307 reviews on Yelp, this restaurant has cemented its reputation as a go-to spot for both locals and tourists.

Joes Shanghai
Pork Steamed Buns” by City Foodsters is licensed under CC BY 2.0. Photo may have been modified, resized, or cropped from original

Located in the heart of Manhattan’s Chinatown at 46 Bowery St, New York, NY 10013, Joe’s Shanghai serves up a variety of traditional dishes, but it’s most famous for its soup dumplings that have become a city-wide sensation.

A 3.8 rating suggests that many find their dining experience here noteworthy.

One Yelp reviewer encapsulates the appeal of Joe’s Shanghai, noting:

Hot, tasty, OG dumplings. Ordered (2) servings of the pork dumplings and scallion pancakes. Bunch of sake too. Finally glad I went here. Service is very fast and ambiance is like a nice Chinatown restaurant.

3. Peter Luger

Have you ever been to Peter Luger? This iconic steakhouse is located in Brooklyn and has a whopping 6,910 reviews on Yelp!

Peter Luger
Luger dinner” by PLBechly is licensed under CC BY-SA 4.0. Photo may have been modified, resized, or cropped from original.

With a 4.0-star average rating, you know you’re in for a mouthwatering experience. They specialize in, you guessed it, steaks.

People rave about their Steak for Two and Creamed Spinach dishes. But don’t worry, there’s more to this place than just meat. You can expect to find an array of scrumptious sides and delightful desserts.

Here’s what a food enthusiasts has to say about their experience:

Visiting Peter Luger is a must for any steak enthusiast. The classic New York steakhouse ambiance sets the stage for a memorable meal. The star is undeniably the dry-aged porterhouse – juicy, flavorful, and cooked just right. The staff’s friendly demeanor and the historic setting make it a perfect spot for tourists seeking an authentic NYC steakhouse experience. Be sure to bring your appetite!

Step into their warm, welcoming atmosphere and let your taste buds be blown away.

4. Lombardi’s Pizza

You’ll find Lombardi’s Pizza at 32 Spring St in New York, NY. This historic pizzeria boasts an impressive 3.8 stars on Yelp and a whopping 6,619 reviews—a testament to its popularity!

Lombardi Pizza
Lombardi’s Pizza” by SimonDoggett is licensed under CC BY 2.0. Photo may have been modified, resized, or cropped from original.

Known for their delicious thin-crust pizza, Lombardi’s offers a variety of mouthwatering options like the classic Margherita and the special Clam Pie.

One satisfied customer mentioned in their review that Lombardi’s Pizza has “the right combination between crust, sauce, and cheese.” It’s not just their must-try slices that get the love – people rave about their Caesar Salad and Calzones too.

With a rich history and a knack for crafting memorable meals, it’s has become a favorite among both locals and visitors alike.

5. Junior’s Restaurant

Close to the dazzling lights of Times Square, you’ll find Junior’s Restaurant enticing your taste buds with its mouthwatering offerings.

Junior's Restaurant
Juniors Restaurant ~ New York City, NY” by Dusty J is licensed under CC BY 2.0. Photo may have been modified, resized, or cropped from original.

Boasting more than 6,051 reviews on Yelp and a solid 4-star rating, this friendly eatery serves as a delicious stop for locals and tourists alike.

A blend of Bakeries, Breakfast & Brunch, and Burgers, Junior’s has something to satisfy every craving. Their iconic location at 1515 Broadway keeps you in the heart of the bustling city while you indulge in their famous dishes.

One reviewer described their dining experience as:

Excellent cheesecake, service was great, the place had a nice feel about it. Would definitely return when I’m back!

Next time you’re in NYC, don’t forget to treat yourself and your taste buds at Junior’s Restaurant.

6. Burger & Lobster – Flatiron NYC

Stepping into Burger & Lobster Flatiron NYC, you’ll be greeted by mouthwatering flavors and diverse crowd in this high-ceiling, wood furnished restaurant. With 5897 reviews and an average rating of 4.2 on Yelp, it’s undoubtedly a popular spot!

Located at 39 W 19th St, New York, they specialize in seafood, burgers, and New American dishes. The simple yet captivating menu offers two main options: a succulent burger and a delicious lobster, both served with fries and a salad.

One ecstatic reviewer wrote, “The lobster roll with lemon garlic butter is to die for; soft, buttery, lobster-packed and seasoned to perfection“.

Burger & Lobster Flatiron is waiting to delight your taste buds in a friendly atmosphere.

7. Clinton Street Baking Company

Visiting Clinton Street Baking Company will reward you with an amazing dining experience. With 5,819 reviews and an impressive average rating of 4.5 stars on Yelp, it’s no wonder this place is a must-try in NYC!

Clinton Street Baking Company
Clinton Street Baking Company (24418329663)” by Abdulla Al Muhairi from Abu Dhabi, UAE is licensed under CC BY 2.0. Photo may have been modified, resized, or cropped from original.

Located at 4 Clinton St, New York City, NY 10002, Clinton Street Baking Company serves American cuisine, highlighting their luscious pancakes and eggs benedict. Perfect for a satisfying brunch or a leisurely weekend meal, this spot never disappoints.

Here’s what a reviewer had to say:

Great place! The pancakes were super thick and the several bites tasted great in the caramel sauce. The sausage was thick as well and the onion sprinkles were a nice touch. Another thing is that the staff was friendly and enthusiastic. I would totally recommend going here again and or for the first time.

Give this delightful restaurant a visit, it’ll surely tantalize your taste buds!

8. Shake Shack Madison Square Park

Visiting New York City and craving a mouthwatering burger? Look no further than Shake Shack Madison Square Park! With 5,808 reviews on Yelp and an average rating of 4 stars, this popular spot is bound to satisfy your taste buds.

Shake Shack Madison Square Park
Shack Order” by SimonDoggett is licensed under CC BY 2.0. Photo may have been modified, resized, or cropped from original.

Located in the southwest corner of the park at 23rd Street and Madison Ave, you’ll find a wide selection of delectable American fast food, including price varies Cheeseburger and price varies Shackburger.

As one Yelp reviewer put it,

Best Burger hands down ever. It’s not your processed meat. It’s fresh, juicy and delectable. The shake sauce is a must not miss either.

While you’re there, don’t forget to try their famous Crinkle Cut Box, which contains 12 servings of their beloved crinkle-cut fries.

9. Grimaldi’s Pizzeria

Grimaldi’s Pizzeria is a famed eatery with over 4,983 reviews on Yelp, boasting an impressive average rating of 4 stars.

Situated at 1 Front St in New York City, this pizzeria has been a favorite of both locals and tourists searching for an authentic NY pizza experience.

Offering Brooklyn-style coal brick oven pizzas, Grimaldi’s uses fresh ingredients, including handmade mozzarella, fresh dough, and their “secret recipe” pizza sauce. The delightful combination of flavors has kept customers coming back for more.

One Yelp reviewer enthuses:

Found this gem while we visited Brooklyn NY. Loved the vintage look and all the photos/frames on the wall. Rustic meets classic Italian esque restaurant. … We opted to share a pizza and salad. 10/10 recommend the salad. We mixed two pizzas and they were outstanding. Perfectly crunchy crust but also chewy pizza to enjoy and savor.

10. Artichoke Basille’s Pizza

With over 4,216 reviews on Yelp, Artichoke Basille’s Pizza is definitely a must-visit for pizza lovers in New York City. They boast a 3.8 average rating and offer savory, Italian-style pizza at their 321 E 14th St location.

Artichoke Basille's Pizza
Best Pizza in Houston 1002091940” by Patrick Feller is licensed under CC BY 2.0. Photo may have been modified, resized, or cropped from original.

As you explore their menu, you’ll find indulgent options like the artichoke pizza and crab pizza. One Yelp reviewer described the artichoke slice:

Specifically, the artichoke pizza was absolutely mind boggling. It tastes like creamy spinach artichoke cheesy soup but somehow in pizza form. The crust was perfectly cooked where you could taste the salty garlicky flavor wonderfully. I topped my slice with extra salt and tried it with red pepper flakes but preferred it without RPF.

So go ahead, treat your taste buds to an Artichoke Basille’s Pizza experience and enjoy a slice (or two) of their delicious offerings. Happy eating!

11. Ippudo Westside

Ippudo Westside is a popular spot in NYC, with a whopping 4,081 reviews on Yelp, and an impressive 4.2 rating!

Ippudo Westside
Ramen at Ippudo Westside” by Bekathwia is licensed under CC BY-SA 2.0. Photo may have been modified, resized, or cropped from original.

Located at 321 W 51st St, New York City, NY 10019-6401, you’ll be delighted to discover a delicious selection of Japanese cuisine. This eatery specializes in ramen, offering a variety of mouthwatering dishes.

One Yelp reviewer raved about their experience,

Fantastic ramen! I recommend the spicy ramen, no adds are needed, the way it comes is PERFECT. The spicy bolognese mixture is to die for mixed into the noodles and broth – YUM. We also got the seasonal cocktail which was perfection during Christmas time. We walked in after our Broadway show, waited about 20 minutes, and had fantastic service. Felt like being back in Japan.

As a friendly reminder, visiting Ippudo Westside during their peak hours can be a challenge, so expect a wait. But, trust us, their ramen bowls are worth the anticipation.

12. Del Frisco’s Double Eagle Steakhouse

In the heart of NYC, Del Frisco’s Double Eagle Steakhouse glows with rave reviews on Yelp. Boasting 3,455 reviews and an impressive average rating of 4.2 stars, you’re in for a delightful experience.

Located at 1221 Avenue of the Americas, they specialize in mouthwatering steaks, fresh seafood, and an award-winning wine selection. As you savor their offerings, you’ll understand the hype.

A recent Yelp review exclaims how the “bone-in ribeye is one of the best” they’ve ever tried, along with their fantastic service that makes you feel right at home.

Next time you find yourself craving an extraordinary dining experience in the Big Apple, remember that Del Frisco’s Double Eagle Steakhouse.

13. Club A Steakhouse

Located in the heart of Midtown East, Club A Steakhouse is a delightful dining spot for all steak lovers. Boasting an impressive 4.5-star rating with over 3,378 reviews on Yelp, this restaurant sets the bar high for steakhouses in New York City.

Their menu includes a wide variety of American and steakhouse cuisines, offering customers the chance to savor everything from a tender 10 oz.

Filet Mignon to a juicy 20 oz. bone-in ribeye. While there, you can also indulge in some of their delectable seafood options, such as shrimp scampi and crab cakes.

One enthusiastic review on Yelp exclaims,

Ambience is A 1! Service is superior, steak is delicious, complimentary dessert was over the top and the owner gave our night a personal touch. We love steak houses and go very often but this deserved recognition. Will definitely be back with the entire family!!!

So, if you’re looking for an exquisite dining experience, Club A Steakhouse should be on your list.

14. Taiyaki NYC

At Taiyaki NYC, you’ll find a tantalizing fusion of Japanese desserts and ice cream.

With over 3341 reviews and an average rating of 4 stars on Yelp, this trendy spot located in the heart of Little Italy is popular for its unique offerings.

One of their signature items is the unicorn taiyaki ice cream, which has amassed hundred rave reviews. A delighted customer exclaimed,

Taiyaki is the cute, colorful, trendy dessert spot to go for all the weekenders looking for a quick and aesthetically pleasing sugar rush.

Enjoy other enchanting dishes such as their fish-shaped cake, black sesame swirl, and custard-filled croyaki.

15. Pies-n-Thighs

Located in Brooklyn, Pies-n-Thighs has a mouthwatering selection of Southern dishes and comfort food.

With over 3,217 reviews on Yelp and a cozy atmosphere, this eatery has become a favorite for many New Yorkers.

The popular restaurant’s average rating is 3.8 stars, showcasing their delicious fare which includes fried chicken, biscuits, and of course, pies. Their menu caters to both breakfast and brunch, so you’ll always find something tempting to try.

One enthusiastic reviewer wrote: “I had the chicken and waffles, which was great! The waffles were fluffy and the chicken was crispy. I also got their pecan pie which was divine!“.

Next time you’re in NYC, make your way to Pies-n-Thighs at 166 S 4th St to savor their scrumptious creations.

16. The Smith

With an impressive 3169 reviews on Yelp, The Smith is the place to be in New York City’s Midtown. Rated an average of 4 stars, this American brasserie offers a delightful variety of dishes, from breakfast to dinner.

Their extensive menu includes popular items like French Toast, Eggs Benedict, and Avocado Toast, pleasing your taste buds and leaving a lasting impression.

Located on 956 2nd Ave, The Smith is undeniably a favorite among locals and visitors alike.

According to a recent review, their Sicilian Baked Eggs are “absolutely delicious,” and Heaven considers The Smith as her “go-to brunch spot.” So, put on your finest brunch attire and dive into the scrumptious world of The Smith!

17. Friedman’s

Friedman’s is a popular spot on the bustling streets of NYC. With 3,022 reviews and a solid 4-star rating, you can’t go wrong taking a seat at their location on 132 W 31st St.

Their menu offers a delightful blend of New American, Breakfast & Brunch, and Wine Bars cuisine, ensuring there’s something for everyone.

One satisfied customer shared on Yelp,

Incredible food with impeccable and efficient service. We had the Reuben, pastrami hash and grilled cheese.
Awesome experience.

With countless dishes to choose from, it’s no wonder that Friedman’s has garnered so many rave reviews. Don’t forget to pair your meal with some selections from their extensive wine list, adding a touch of sophistication to your dining adventure.

18. Amélie

If you’re searching for a popular French restaurant in NYC, look no further than Amélie. With an impressive 2,925 reviews on Yelp, this charming spot boasts a 4.3-star rating.

Located at 22 W 8th St, New York, you’ll find a cozy atmosphere that complements the exquisite French cuisine and wine selection.

One satisfied Yelp reviewer raved about their experience at Amélie, mentioning the “fantastic food and superb service.”

At Amélie, you’ll also enjoy the variety of flavors offered, ranging from scrumptious appetizers to mouthwatering desserts. The restaurant’s flair for crafting delectable dishes reflects the rich culture of French cuisine.

19. ilili Restaurant

Guess what? ilili Restaurant has an impressive 2773 reviews on Yelp, with a shining 4-star average rating.

Located in the heart of the Flatiron District at 236 5th Ave, this Lebanese haven will transport your taste buds to a culinary paradise.

Their menu offers a tantalizing blend of Lebanese and Mediterranean cuisine, making it a splendid choice for special occasions or group gatherings.

One delighted patron shares their experience,

Been here a few times. Most recently for their New Year’s Eve dinner. Food has been delicious and service excellent every time. The kibbeh naye is a favorite and not all restaurants serve that delicacy.

As you explore the diverse dishes, you’ll find ilili is more than just a restaurant – it’s an enchanting dining experience.

20. Bua Thai Ramen & Robata Grill

With an impressive 2,650 reviews on Yelp, Bua Thai Ramen & Robata Grill scores a remarkable 4.4 average rating.

Located at 1611 2nd Ave, New York, this eatery welcomes you to explore their diverse menu, laden with Thai, Ramen, and Vegetarian offerings.

One satisfied customer left a delightful review:

Loved the food here! The service is nice and I loved the ramen here! Really special and would recommend.

Don’t miss the opportunity to check out their creative cocktails if you’re a fan of unique and refreshing beverages. Next time you’re in the city, make sure to drop by and experience the flavors of Bua Thai Ramen & Robata Grill!

21. Babbo

Stepping into Babbo, you’ll find yourself immersed in the vibrant world of Italian cuisine right in the heart of New York City.

With 2624 reviews and an impressive 4-star rating on Yelp, this restaurant truly brings the authentic flavors of Italy to your plate.

Located at 110 Waverly Pl, their menu celebrates a delightful mix of traditional and innovative dishes. Embrace the art of pasta or treat your taste buds to the exquisite osso bucco.

One Yelp reviewer shared their touching experience: “Amazing Italian cuisine with genuinely friendly people who are passionate about their food and wine.”

A visit to Babbo promises a memorable dining experience as you indulge in the warmth and richness of Italian flavors.

22. Jongro BBQ

When you crave some delectable Korean BBQ in New York City, look no further than the ever-popular Jongro BBQ. With an astounding 2,567 reviews and a 4.2-star rating, it’s clear people are singing its praises.

Located at 22 W 32nd St, Jongro offers a cozy ambiance and flavorful barbecue selections that will transport your taste buds.

Their menu features classics like Korean, Barbeque, and Bars, so there’s something to suit everyone’s cravings.

One patron, enamored with Jongro, said in their review:

A super reliable KBBQ spot that I frequent, however lines are always long so be warned to get here early if you want to be seated early. Their meat is always fresh and my favorite part of korean restaurants are their ban chan and Jongro definitely has some yummy ban chans to munch on as you are waiting for your meat to be served.

Take a chance on this charismatic eatery – it’s time to treat yourself to some delightful Korean BBQ at Jongro BBQ!

23. Jack’s Wife Freda

Are you craving a delightful dining experience? Look no further than Jack’s Wife Freda, a restaurant with over 2,466 reviews on Yelp, boasting an impressive 3.9-star average rating.

Jack's Wife Freda
An amazing breakfast at Jack’s Wife Freda” by Bex.Walton is licensed under CC BY 2.0. Photo may have been modified, resized, or cropped from original.

Located at 226 Lafayette St, New York, this cozy eatery offers a delightful combination of Breakfast & Brunch, Mediterranean, and New American cuisine.

Get ready to be captivated by their array of mouth-watering dishes. One satisfied customer raved,

Food, service, and ambiance were all excellent. I loved the all day breakfast menu. Jacks breakfast’s steak was cooked perfectly with enough flavor. The burger was tender. The waffle was served with fresh fruit.

Don’t miss out on this culinary experience at Jack’s Wife Freda, a fan favorite among New York City foodies.

24. Ellen’s Stardust Diner

Located in the heart of New York City’s Theater District, Ellen’s Stardust Diner is a fun and lively spot for a meal.

With a staggering 2427 reviews on Yelp and an average rating of 4.0 stars, you know you’re in for a treat.

This entertaining restaurant offers a wide variety of American, diner-style, and soup dishes. The cherry on top? Their world-famous singing waitstaff!

When visiting, savor their quintessential New York eatery at 1650 Broadway. One recent visitor shared their excitement saying,

This place is the best place to experience live broadway music and food. Great for families and kids. Food is hearty and standard diner fare but not bad at all. It’s awesome when your servers start singing!! Would recommend wholeheartedly. And the long line moves fast!

25. Nom Wah Tea Parlor

When visiting New York City, Nom Wah Tea Parlor is definitely a place you’d like to check out. With over 2,382 reviews on Yelp, this historic eatery boasts an average rating of 3.6 stars.

Located in the heart of Chinatown at 13 Doyers St, Nom Wah offers a delightful selection of dim sum and an array of teas to choose from.

One happy customer expressed their satisfaction with the House Special Roast Pork Bun,

One of the best experiences. Try there pork soup dumplings with a little vinegar. It’s the best. There pan fried noodles are also especially delicious. The egg rolls are gigantic but oh so good can totally share. They are cash or American Express only. When back in NYC this is a must stop.

So, why not treat yourself to some delicious dim sum and experience a piece of New York City’s culinary history?

25 Restaurants in NYC with the MOST Reviews on Yelp: A Recap

With so many options available, it’s always a good idea to trust your fellow food enthusiasts.

Arguably, the heart of the city’s culinary scene lies in Yelp where diners share their experience and recommendations.

A few examples from the list include Amélie, a charming French wine bar in Greenwich Village; Artichoke Basille’s Pizza, a must-visit for Italian pizza lovers; and Club A Steakhouse, a destination for those who seek to indulge in luxurious seafood experiences.

From Italian cuisine to French wine bars, these diverse eateries cater to a variety of tastes and preferences.

So, whether you’re a local or just visiting New York City, make the most of these remarkable Yelp-reviewed restaurants.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *