25 Restaurants in NYC with Highest Yelp Ratings: Your Must-Try Dining Guide

With an overwhelming number of top-notch eateries to choose from, zeroing in on where to dine in the Big Apple might seem like a daunting task.

Luckily, we’ve compiled a list of the 25 highest-rated restaurants on Yelp, making your choice a bit easier.

These amazing eateries have earned their top spots due to outstanding cuisine, memorable ambiance, and exceptional service.

So, prepare yourself to embark on a gastronomic adventure through the streets of NYC!

1. Mr. Jones Supper Club

Tucked away in the vibrant streets of New York City, Mr. Jones Supper Club has become a culinary gem with a perfect 5-star rating on Yelp.

With 68 reviews to its name, this intimate eatery has captivated diners with its finely prepared dishes and unique dining experience.

The type of food they offer leans towards an upscale, modern cuisine, tailored to create a memorable dining experience.

One patron vividly described the restaurant as an:

Intimate dining experience with a warm, inviting and exciting atmosphere. Mr. Jones Supper Club concentrates on what matters – good food, and good company. … The dishes are creative, well-thought out combinations of flavors that will wow your senses and eyes. The experience, execution of the dishes, and attention to detail are nearly flawless.

So, if you’re looking to indulge in a top-rated dining experience in NYC, Mr. Jones Supper Club should undoubtedly be on your list.

2. Nneji

Nneji, an African restaurant situated in Astoria, New York, stands out in NYC’s vast culinary landscape.

It’s known for its Nigerian cuisine, offering a variety of traditional dishes that have garnered a strong following on Yelp. Boasting an impressive number of 57 reviews, the establishment has received widespread acclaim for its authentic flavors.

A patron on Yelp expressed their delight, sharing that the egusi and harissa chicken were “delicious” and commending the owner’s warm hospitality.

Located at 32-20 34th Ave, Nneji invites both locals and tourists to savor a piece of Nigeria in the bustling borough of Astoria.

3. bōm

Nestled at 17 W 19th St, between Avenue Of The Americas & 5th Ave in the Flatiron district of New York City, bōm stands as a beacon of culinary excellence.

With a perfect 5.0 rating on Yelp from 24 reviews, this esteemed Korean restaurant proudly boasts a coveted Michelin star, signaling its outstanding quality.

At bōm, every dish is a symphony of flavors, showcasing a meticulous blend of high-quality ingredients. The menu features standout items like succulent Wagyu beef and the lavish decadence of caviar, each ingredient speaking volumes about the restaurant’s commitment to culinary excellence.

A patron’s review encapsulates the experience:

Elevated my culinary expectations with a symphony of flavors, each element demonstrating a commitment to culinary excellence.

For those looking to indulge in a unique and memorable dining experience in NYC, bōm is a must-visit.

4. The Kasbah Café

Take a stroll to The Kasbah Café, a charming spot in New York, where divine Mediterranean cuisine awaits. With an impressive 5.0 stars on Yelp from 25 reviews, your taste buds are in for a treat!

This cozy café, nestled at 3919 Greenpoint Ave, offers a delightful array of coffee, tea, breakfast, and brunch options. Let their sandwiches and pastries transport you to a culinary oasis like no other in the city.

One happy customer reviewed The Kasbah Café, saying:

This Algerian cafe has the best freshly baked baguette I’ve ever had. The merguez sandwich is literal bliss. The owners are the sweetest people you’ll ever meet and the cafe itself is so cozy. I always love stopping by here!

So, next time you’re craving a scrumptious bite in the Big Apple, The Kasbah Café is eagerly waiting to serve you their finest treats.

5. Bella Beans Cafe

Located in Staten Island, Bella Beans Cafe receives high praise with a 4.9-star rating on Yelp, based on 26 reviews. This delightful eatery specializes in baked goods, desserts, and café fare.

At Bella Beans Cafe, you’ll appreciate their range of menu offerings, such as enticing pastries and creamy gelato.

A recent Yelp review raves,

Everything is so delicious and the staff is always very friendly and helpful. We especially love the crumb cake (original), the rainbow cake & cookies, the bellaccino, and the freshly filled cannolis!

This lovely spot at 1371 Bay St offers both indoor and outdoor seating.

Indulge in the deliciousness Bella Beans Cafe has to offer, and experience this highly-rated establishment for yourself.

6. Avenue X Bagels

If you’re a bagel lover, look no further than Avenue X Bagels in Brooklyn. This delightful spot boasts a near-perfect Yelp rating of 4.9 stars based on 33 reviews.

Conveniently located in the heart of Brooklyn, they offer a mouthwatering selection of bagels, sandwiches, and breakfast dishes.

One Yelp reviewer raved about their Ave X Omelette, while others adored their Nutella French Toast. Don’t miss their artisanal bagel selection that includes a variety of flavors, from the classics to some inventive surprises.

Offering both takeout and dine-in service in a cozy atmosphere, Avenue X Bagels is a satisfying destination for both your breakfast and lunch cravings. Their bagels are made fresh daily, so you can always count on a scrumptious experience.

7. Nisars Halal Cart

Located in Forest Hills, Nisars Halal Cart offers mouth-watering Halal cuisine. With an impressive 4.9 average rating on Yelp, this quaint spot has garnered numerous positive reviews.

One satisfied customer raved about their experience, emphasizing the delicious food and friendly service:

My favorite Halal cart in the area, and there are hundreds! I get the falafal platter with rice and salad, topped with white, red and a special green cilantro hot sauce. Great to have him in the neighborhood.

So if you’re strolling around the streets of NYC, don’t hesitate to swing by Nisars Halal Cart for a delightful meal!

Read Ron M.‘s review of Nisars Halal Cart on Yelp

8. Pastrami & Grill

Located in Hell’s Kitchen, Pastrami & Grill shines with its delectable offerings. With an impressive average rating on Yelp, you can tell they’ve earned their spot on the list.

Their menu boasts an array of delicious dishes, ranging from pastrami sandwiches to more indulgent options. Here’s what a satisfied customer had to say:

Best pastrami sandwich I’ve ever had! The meat was so tender and the flavors were on point.

So, if you’re in the mood for some mouth-watering pastrami and a delightful food experience, swing by Pastrami & Grill and treat yourself!

9. Sunday Coffee & Conscious Eatery

Located in New York City, Sunday Coffee & Conscious Eatery impresses patrons with its delectable food options and cozy ambiance.

With an impressive 4.9 average rating on Yelp, it has garnered rave reviews from locals and visitors alike.

Specializing in a blend of dishes, you’ll find everything from chicken sandwiches to vegan options. A customer shares their excitement about the vegan offerings, mentioning that the food is truly delicious:

Must try to japanese curry! The chick’n is delicious everything is made in house by the owner/chef Chris, who started with a food truck in Miami. Lot’s of gluten free options too. And there are heat lamps it’s cozy any time of year.

Your visit to Sunday Coffee & Conscious Eatery might just be the beginning of a love affair with this delightful spot.

Read Katie B.‘s review of Sunday Coffee & Conscious Eatery on Yelp

10. Café Calaca

At Café Calaca, you’ll find a cozy destination nestled in Brooklyn’s Clinton Hill and Bedford-Stuyvesant neighborhood. This friendly café boasts an impressive average rating of 4.9 stars on Yelp, based on 20 reviews.

Indulge in their delightful menu offering a mix of coffee, tea, and light snacks. Located at 505 Franklin Ave in Brooklyn, Café Calaca continues to charm locals and visitors alike.

A recommendation on Yelp highlights their coffee, as well as their friendly atmosphere:

Love this spot! Super nice staff, and they’ve done a nice reno to the indoor and outdoor spaces. The coffee is solid, empanadas savory and filling, and the chilaquiles are hangover kryptonite. Check it out!

Indeed, a must-try in NYC!

11. Billy’s Hot Dog Cart

If you’re strolling through the Upper West Side, Billy’s Hot Dog Cart is the perfect stop for a quick, delicious meal.

With an impressive 4.9 average rating and over 84 reviews on Yelp, they’re renowned for their tasty hot dogs, pretzels, and more.

Located at 327 Central Park West, this food stand offers both regular and spicy hot dogs to please every palate. A food lover even mentioned their amazing experience, stating how the hot dogs are “slightly spicy, and very tasty.”

Facing Central Park, the location is simply ideal for enjoying authentic New York City street food.

12. Brooklyn Bodega Sub Hub

Nestled in the South Slope area of Brooklyn, Brooklyn Bodega Sub Hub has made quite the name for itself.

With an impressive 52 reviews on Yelp, they’ve managed to secure a 4.9-star average rating. Quite the accomplishment!

You’ll find this delightful spot at 471 7th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215, offering scrumptious sandwiches, salads, and more. Their menu is filled with delicious options, ensuring that there’s something for everyone to enjoy.

One satisfied visitor proclaimed,

This place feels like a throwback to the 80s 90s of park slope when they made great sandwiches & prices weren’t crazy. They are so friendly & everything I’ve tried so far has been so fresh & tasty!

It seems that Brooklyn Bodega Sub Hub has definitely made its mark among the 25 highest rated restaurants in NYC on Yelp.

Read Randall M.‘s review of Brooklyn Bodega Sub Hub on Yelp

13. That Place

Stepping into That Place, you’ll immediately notice its unique charm. With over 59 glowing reviews on Yelp and a stellar 4.9 average rating, you’re in for a treat. Located in the heart of Manhattan, That Place specializes in delectable Mediterranean cuisine.

One Yelp reviewer exclaims,

Phenomenal!!! The 14 course omakase on Fri & Sat at 5pm is a phenomenal value. And the otoro with black truffle sauce is one of the tastiest things I’ve had in recent memory! The chefs really care about their craft. And the service is kind & genuine. Loved how relaxed the space feels!

That Place invites you to experience their cozy ambiance and enjoy their mouthwatering dishes. Don’t miss out on this highly-rated sensation!

Read Johnny P.‘s review of That Place on Yelp

14. Mr Khao Man Gai

Located in Long Island City, Mr Khao Man Gai is a highly rated food truck that offers delicious Thai dishes. Averaging an impressive 4.9 stars based on 42 reviews, you are in for a delightful culinary experience.

This food truck specializes in delightful Hainan dishes, including its famous namesake, Khao Man Gai. In a rave review, a customer praised the generous portions and scrumptious taste.

Lasting for over four years in business, they have also earned a reputation for being eco-friendly and supporting the local community.

So, when you crave some mouth-watering Thai cuisine, make sure to pay a visit to Mr. Khao Man Gai.

15. C&B Luncheonette

Located in Ridgewood, New York, C&B Luncheonette is a delightful eatery with an impressive 4.9 average rating on Yelp. They have amassed 33 reviews from satisfied customers!

Serving up mouthwatering Breakfast & Brunch options, guests love their cozy atmosphere. One satisfied reviewer on Yelp praises their fantastic food and attentive service:

Yummy breakfast joint. Friendly owner! Customer service really goes a long way with reviews.

Stop by C&B Luncheonette on your next visit to NYC and treat your taste buds to a delightful culinary experience.

16. The Grand Feast

Located at 854 Amsterdam Ave, this delightful eatery has earned an impressive average rating of 4.9 stars from 29 Yelp reviews.

A charming spot, their menu boasts an eclectic mix of American and European dishes, inviting you to linger over lunch or dinner.

Indulge in The Grand Feast’s range of breakfast and brunch options, serving up scrumptious classics like burgers and pasta, as well as seafood. Be sure to have a peek at their exquisite menu and start planning your next feast for your taste buds.

One diner shared her experience in this review,

Oh my, Grand Feast was a gem of a stumble upon! We had the Tuna Tartare, Duck a la Orange and seafood pasta special. They were all delicious! The service is EXCELLENT, reasonable prices and generous portions . We have lunch for tomorrow.

So slip into this friendly space, indulge in a delicious meal, and let The Grand Feast transport you to a world of irresistible flavors.

17. DB Breakfast

With an impressive rating of 4.9 stars from 34 reviews, DB Breakfast has become a must-visit spot for breakfast enthusiasts in New York City.

Located in the vibrant East Village, this eatery specializes in New American cuisine and tantalizing brunch dishes.

One satisfied customer raved:

Great coffee shop in Rutherford. Owned by a hard working family. Great coffee , desserts, breakfast sandwiches and bubble tea. Highly Recommend!

DB Breakfast offers outdoor seating, delivery, and takeout options to cater to your preferences.

Savor the scrumptious offerings in this delightful restaurant, and make your breakfast experience truly unforgettable.

18. Sonbobs

Sonbobs is a delightful spot in Astoria, New York. With an impressive 4.8 stars from 65 reviews on Yelp, it seems customers can’t get enough.

You would find them at 34-15 28th Ave, offering delicious choices of Coffee & Tea, Desserts, and Sandwiches.

One delighted customer shared their experience:

A must stop for a quirky little cafe! Super funky and friendly. Need anything? It’s probably for sale in the cafe. Coffee was good and reasonably priced. Bagel was good and had lots of creme cheese. Cute little muffins and pastries. A great local business to give money to!

What a treat for your taste buds! Sonbobs is a great choice when you’re in NYC.

19. Doctor’s Cave Cafe

Located in Brooklyn’s bustling Bedford-Stuyvesant Historic District, Doctor’s Cave Cafe holds a dazzling 4.8-star rating on Yelp and has received 44 delightful reviews.

One patron mentioned in their review that this family-run cafe was “nice gem to find”:

I am visiting in the neighborhood and was looking for a coffee place. This was a nice gem to find. Got an iced oat milk latte and the pumpkin salad. I love how many vegan and whole food options there are. The woman seemed nice and the staff had fun banter between each other. I was quickly in and out, but will likely go and spend more time while I’m here.

Doctor’s Cave Cafe serves mouthwatering egg sandwiches, chicken dishes, and omelettes. Their enticing drink menu includes espresso, smoothies, and juice, perfect for a quick pick-me-up throughout the day.

20. ME Chicken Rice

Located in New York, NY, ME Chicken Rice boasts a 4.8-star average rating on Yelp. Specializing in flavorful Thai dishes, their steamed chicken over rice is a customer favorite.

With over 120 reviews, you can truly trust the popularity of this dining spot. Diners love the soup that comes with their chicken rice, praising its delicious and flavorful taste.

Located in the heart of the city, it’s a convenient stop for a delightful meal. You’ll want to check out ME Chicken Rice and see for yourself why it’s rated among the top 25 restaurants in NYC.

21. Punjabi Junction Of 87th

Good news, your craving for delicious Indian cuisine can be satisfied at Punjabi Junction Of 87th in New York City! Nestled in the vibrant area of Yorkville, Upper East Side, this restaurant is truly a must-try spot.

With over 66 glowing reviews on Yelp, they’ve earned an impressive average rating. Brace yourself for mouthwatering dishes like Spicy Chicken Sandwich On Roll, and Chicken Curry – each carrying a rave review.

Location, you ask? Find them at 1665 1st Ave, New York, NY 10028. Be prepared to indulge your taste buds, you can take it from a Yelp reviewer who simply raved,

Food is fresh, service fast at this easily missed Indian take away spot. Veggie pakora ($2 for 3)and samosa($2) make yummy cheap snacks. Chicken curry was delicious. Everything tastes homemade, $14 comes w two veggie sides. NYT reviews are posted on the storefront.

So, swing by Punjabi Junction Of 87th and let your culinary adventure unfold in the bustling heart of NYC.

22. Selo

In the bustling neighborhood of Astoria, you’ll find Selo, a highly-rated Modern European restaurant.

With a remarkable average rating of 4.8 stars and 118 reviews on Yelp, Selo continues to impress its patrons.

Their menu offers a delightful array of dishes, from Chicken with Mlinci to Stuffed Yellow Peppers. One satisfied reviewer raves about the fresh and light Greek salad, which exhibits a generous flavor of feta cheese.

Immerse yourself in the cozy and inviting ambiance while experiencing the delicious taste of home-cooked meals at Selo. Your palate will thank you!

23. Jimbo Slims

Jimbo Slims is a popular spot in Brooklyn that has received an impressive 4.8-rating on Yelp. With over 39 reviews, this restaurant has left quite an impression on its guests.

Situated at 524 Graham Ave, you’ll find yourself immersed in the vibrant atmosphere this eatery offers. They specialize in serving delicious tacos, mouth-watering cocktails, and fine wine.

One ecstatic customer mentioned,

Amazing!!! Grilled cheese is to die for and amazing drinks and bartenders Phil is a awesome owner and is definitely very committed to his customers and business!

It’s clear that your experience at Jimbo Slims will be nothing short of amazing.

24. Joe’s Italian Deli

At Joe’s Italian Deli, located in Belmont, you’ll discover a highly-rated Italian eatery. With an impressive rating of 4.8 stars on Yelp, this delightful spot has garnered rave reviews from food enthusiasts.

Over 187 Yelp reviewers have shared their satisfaction with Joe’s Italian Deli. So, while you’re in New York, savor the delicious experience of their chicken cutlet with prosciutto.

One customer review highlights the restaurant’s fantastic ambiance and authentic flavors,

If you looking for authentic Italian dishes, this is the place to go been going to this place for the past three years and always glad that I do service is 100 out of 100 family owned business. You are welcome as soon as you walk in the door and upon arriving they have so much selection. … Everything looks so good and delicious.

25. Wallington Deli

At the cozy Wallington Deli, you will find a lovely selection of mouthwatering sandwiches and more. With an impressive 4.8-star rating from 38 reviews on Yelp, this deli definitely knows how to please its customers.

Located at 181 Paterson Ave, Wallington, NJ, visitors can indulge in an assortment of scrumptious Italian heroes and delectable tuna subs. Their diverse menu offerings cater to various palates as well.

One satisfied customer shared her delight with their experience,

So I have to say, this might be the best sandwich I have ever had. My friend got me hooked on this place. It’s a small mom and pop shop with no bells and whistles but their sandwiches speak for themselves. I got their chicken cutlet with fresh mozzarella and peppers. WOW! Their bread is to die for.

So next time you’re in the area, treat yourself to a delightful experience at Wallington Deli!

25 Restaurants in NYC with the Highest Rating on Yelp: A Recap

If you’re looking for top-notch dining experiences in the Big Apple, fret not! This list presents 25 outstanding restaurants in New York City, each highly rated on Yelp.

These culinary havens offer a variety of cuisines, so you’ll never run out of options for your taste buds!

Some pro tips for you: Before heading out to dine, quickly review the restaurant’s online menu to match your tastes, check reservation details to skip long waits, and glance at customer reviews for deeper insights.

Enjoy your food adventure in one of the world’s most vibrant cities—New York!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *