30 Best Pizza Places in NYC: A Tasty Tour for Your Palate

Trying to pick the top pizza spots in NYC? It’s quite the challenge! The city’s bursting with legendary pizza joints, each more tempting than the last.

This list of the 30 Best Pizza Places in NYC will help you indulge in the city’s most delicious pies, without regret.

From classic New York-style slices to mouthwatering Neapolitan, you will embark on a tasty journey through the city’s diverse pizza landscape.

So grab a friend, and get ready to explore these 30 must-visit NYC pizza establishments.

1. Juliana’s

At Juliana’s, you’ll indulge in pizzas that are fresh from their 800° coal-fired oven. Located in Brooklyn, this Italian restaurant offers a cozy atmosphere to savor their irresistible delicacies.

With 2,746 reviews on Yelp and an impressive average rating of 4.4 stars, you can trust that their mouth-watering pizza creations won’t disappoint. Their Tie Dye Pizza, for example, has won many hearts with its tomato sauce, pesto, and fresh mozzarella combination.

One customer praised Juliana, saying:

Nice restaurant and good location! Amazing spot for pizza! One of the best and very fun tasting menu with a wide variety of pizza flavor. The quality was fantastic. The staff was friendly too. Served our food promptly.

As you bite into their scrumptious pizza, surrounded by charming rustic decor, you’ll understand why many consider Juliana’s a must-visit spot in New York City.

2. Rubirosa

If you’re in the mood for authentic Italian pizza, Rubirosa should be on your list. Located in the heart of Nolita, this cozy spot has a fantastic 4.3-star rating on Yelp, with over 3.2k reviews from delighted pizza enthusiasts.

 Rubirosa
Rubirosa Supreme Pizza” by Cole Kennedy is marked with Public Domain Mark 1.0. Photo may have been modified, resized, or cropped from original.

While you’re there, don’t miss out on their famous Vodka sauce pizza, a fan favorite. One Yelp reviewer raves,

I am obsessed with Rubirosa! Every time I come to New York and want pizza I go straight here. I get the vodka pie which has a nice thin crispy crust and a delicious sauce. RR wanted pepperoni so we did 1/2 and 1/2. Absolutely love it. Also tried the cannolis and they were pretty good.

So when you’re craving a slice of pizza perfection, head on over to 235 Mulberry St, and indulge in the flavorful-ness that is Rubirosa.

3. John’s of Bleecker Street

At John’s of Bleecker Street, you’ll find an iconic pizza spot in NYC’s vibrant West Village. With a 4.2 average rating based on over 2,000 Yelp reviews, feast your eyes on some of the tastiest pizzas in town.

John's of Bleecker Street
The Boom Pie at John’s of Bleecker Street (01538)” by Rhododendrites is licensed under CC BY-SA 4.0. Photo may have been modified, resized, or cropped from original.

Located at 278 Bleecker St, New York City, NY 10014, it offers a cozy ambiance, making you feel right at home.

A recent review from a delighted customer praises their experience at John’s:

Real real good pizza. Old fashioned brick oven style, very saucy. They A classic spot, with a fun vibe inside. It’s a can’t miss spot on your pizza tour of NY.

From classics like Margherita to specially crafted pies, explore the flavors that keep pizza-lovers coming back for more.

4. Philomena’s

At Philomena’s, you’ll find a well-loved pizzeria that has been a crowd favorite since 2016.

Located in New York City, this delightful spot offers a tasty selection of pizza squares, NY-style slices, and Neapolitan pies.

Feeling curious about their Yelp reputation? This bustling locale impresses with numerous reviews, holding an average rating of 4.7 stars. Eager patrons from near and far gather to enjoy their luscious pizza offerings.

One happy customer, applauded Philomena’s, stating:

Best pizza in NYC hands down! This is a simple place but each bite of pizza packs a ton of depth and flavor. Can’t recommend it enough.

Next time you’re in the area, don’t miss out on this friendly pizza joint – drop by Philomena’s for a slice or two, and experience their delicious pizzas while immersing yourself in the vibrant NYC atmosphere.

5. L & B Spumoni Gardens

Visiting L & B Spumoni Gardens is a delightful experience for pizza lovers like you. Located at 2725 86th Street Brooklyn, NY, this pizza place showcases a marvelous Sicilian square pizza and creamy ice cream.

L & B Spumoni Gardens
L&B Spumoni Gardens Square Pizza” by TheGirlsNY is licensed under CC BY-SA 2.0. Photo may have been modified, resized, or cropped from original.

You’ll be pleased to know that the famous L & B Spumoni Gardens has a fantastic Yelp rating with over 4,682 reviews, holding an average of 4.2 stars.

As a pizza aficionado, you’ll appreciate a particular review from a satisfied customer on Yelp:

One of the top pizza spots in Brooklyn! Must haves: Sicilian slice and Philly cheese steak! Such a perfect spot in the summer! Grab a slice and hang out with friends on the benches they have outside. Don’t forget to finish off your meal with their famous spumoni icee!

Undeniably, the experience is not just about their scrumptious pizza, but also the pleasant ambiance that enhances your dining affair.

6. Lucali

At Lucali, you’ll be delighted by the delicious pizza flavors crafted by chef/owner Mark Iacono right in the heart of Brooklyn’s Carroll Gardens.

 Lucali
Lucali Pizza” by Praneeth Thalla is licensed under CC BY-SA 4.0. Photo may have been modified, resized, or cropped from original.

With a 4.5-star rating on Yelp from over 1,000 reviews, you know you’re in for a treat.

One satisfied customer, describes her experience:

My favorite pizza joint in Brooklyn! Perfect brick oven pizza, amazing sauce/cheese combo, delicious”

Don’t miss the chance to visit this famous pizza spot and try their heavenly pizzas for yourself. Who knows, you may just have found your new favorite pizza destination!

7. L’industrie Pizzeria

With a 4.5-star average on Yelp based on over 1,300 reviews, L’industrie Pizzeria has become a favorite spot for pizza lovers in New York City.

Conveniently located at 104 Christopher St in the West Village, this cozy pizzeria offers a delectable array of pizza slices for you to enjoy.

One pleased customer raved about their Margherita Slice and mentioned, “The pizza was amazing with the perfect balance of sauce, cheese, and crust.”

L’industrie Pizzeria invites you to savor their scrumptious creations and experience a delightful slice of NYC.

Make sure to plan your visit and perhaps discover a new favorite pizza joint in the process.

8. New Park Pizza

When visiting New York City, you must try New Park Pizza located in Queens. This beloved spot has an impressive Yelp rating of 4 stars, based on over 1000 reviews.

New Park Pizza
New York Style Pizza New Park” by Wil540 art is licensed under CC BY-SA 4.0. Photo may have been modified, resized, or cropped from original.

Craving mouthwatering pizza? New Park Pizza won’t disappoint with their generous toppings and perfectly cooked slices. One satisfied customer raves about their delicious pepperoni, cheese pies, and calzones.

Don’t worry about getting lost; they are conveniently located at 15671 Cross Bay Blvd, Howard Beach, Queens.

So, next time you find yourself in the Big Apple, treat yourself to a slice of pizza heaven at New Park Pizza.

9. Joe’s Pizza

In the heart of Greenwich Village, you’ll find a beloved New York slice at Joe’s Pizza. With origins dating back to the 70s, this spot is a true city staple.

Joe's Pizza
Joe’s Pizza Times Square NYC” by Steam Pipe Trunk Distribution Venue is licensed under CC BY 2.0. Photo may have been modified, resized, or cropped from original.

Their thin crust pies are flavored with a sweet tomato sauce, and the cheese pulls are nothing short of Instagram-worthy! You’ll definitely want to try their classic late-night street slice.

Currently holding 4 stars on Yelp with thousands of reviews, one happy customer described Joe’s Pizza as having “a crispy crust, oozing cheese, and a flavorful sauce that keeps you coming back for more.” Indulge your taste buds at this iconic NYC pizza place!

10. Paulie Gee’s

Searching for some incredible pizza in NYC? Look no further! At Paulie Gee’s, the mouthwatering flavors and unique combinations will make your taste buds dance.

 Paulie Gee's
Pizza by Candlelight (Red), Paulie Gee’s Pizzeria, Brooklyn NY” by Gary Soup is licensed under CC BY 2.0. Photo may have been modified, resized, or cropped from original.

Located in Greenpoint, Brooklyn, this pizzeria has become a go-to spot for pizza enthusiasts.

With over 912 reviews on Yelp, Paulie Gee’s maintains an impressive average rating of 4.5 stars.

Take a peek at this glowing review from a happy pizza lover,

Great pizza spot in Brooklyn- the owner goes from table to table to meet and greet everyone. There’s a hospitable touch to this place. The pizza takes a little time to come out, but it’s really good.

Their menu caters to a wide variety of palates, ranging from classic Margherita to the more adventurous offerings like their famous Hellboy pizza. With so many delightful choices, it’s hard to go wrong with this beloved Brooklyn pizza joint.

11. Joe & Pat’s Pizzeria

Welcome to Joe & Pat’s Pizzeria, a family-owned pizza place at 168 1st Ave, New York, NY. You will love their mouth-watering pizza and pasta, that has won the hearts of locals since 1960.

On Yelp, they have a noteworthy 317 reviews, showcasing their popularity among New York’s pizza connoisseurs with 4.1 average rating.

Their delightful 11th St & 10th St location provides a perfect place to savor their tasty offerings.

A recent review sums it up nicely: “Delicious thin crust pizza with the perfect cheese-to-sauce ratio.”

12. VEZZO NYCThinCrust Pizza

Located in Manhattan’s Murray Hill neighborhood, VEZZO NYCThinCrust Pizza has made a mark with its impossibly thin crust pizzas. With a remarkable 1,408 reviews on Yelp, the majority of diners rave about their delicious offerings.

A Yelp user’s review praises Vezzo’s Shroomtown Pizza,

Excellent crispy, thin, pizza. Wonderful apple cheddar salad. Great deal for happy hour pitcher for a free pie!

They also have a variety of appetizing salad options to complement, making VEZZO a must-visit destination.

13. Don Antonio

Looking for the best Neapolitan pizza in Manhattan? You’ll be delighted to know about Don Antonio.

Don Antonio
Burrata Roberto Pizza, Don Antonio, New York” by T.Tseng is licensed under CC BY 2.0. Photo may have been modified, resized, or cropped from original.

Located at 309 West 50th Street, this pizzeria has garnered an impressive 4.0-star rating from over 1,708 reviews on Yelp.

Intrigued? Well, you certainly should be! One Yelp reviewer gushes about the flavorful Fried Pizza,

This is my go to pizza spot when I’m
In NYC. I discovered it one trip and now make a pilgrimage. The deep fried pizza is my favorite but I’ve enjoyed a few others. All are fresh, perfectly made, and delicious. Thin crust, wood fire oven, and fresh ingredients.

But wait, there’s more – they also offer gluten-free options for those with dietary restrictions.

So, treat your taste buds with an unforgettable pizza experience at Don Antonio.

14. Kesté Pizza & Vino

If you’re in search of authentic Neapolitan pizza, Kesté Pizza & Vino is your go-to spot. Located on 77 Fulton St, New York, NY, this popular pizzeria delights customers with delicious pizza and a wonderful ambience.

Kesté Pizza & Vino
Kesté Pizza” by Edsel L is licensed under CC BY-SA 2.0. Photo may have been modified, resized, or cropped from original.

Boasting an impressive 4.2 stars on Yelp with over 1,876 reviews, Kesté makes a vibrant dining destination in NYC.

Their Margherita pizza is highly praised, as one reviewer describes it as having an “amazing crust – chewy on the inside and burnt to a crisp on the outer edges” in their review.

No need to hesitate—treat yourself to Kesté’s divine Margherita and Marinara pizzas, and enjoy the bountiful flavors this NYC pizzeria has to offer.

15. Di Fara Pizza

Di Fara Pizza in New York is a must-visit spot for pizza enthusiasts like you. With nearly 69 reviews on Yelp and an impressive 3.8-star average rating, you know it’s got to be worth checking out.

Di Fara Pizza
Pizza at Di Fara Pizza” by Sejan at English Wikipedia is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0. Photo may have been modified, resized, or cropped from original.

Their location at 108 South St, New York, NY 10038, makes it easily accessible for your pizza adventures.

One reviewer said, “I can’t say enough about the deliciousness of Di Fara’s pizza! The crust is perfect, and their sauce is incredibly flavorful.”. This just goes to show the quality of the pies they crank out daily!

So, next time you’re in the mood for some mouth-watering pizza, be sure to swing by Di Fara Pizza.

16. Roberta’s

With its Bee Sting Pizza being quite popular, Roberta’s in Brooklyn has earned a lot of praise for its unique flavors and great atmosphere.

Roberta's
Roberta’s Pizza” by nickgraywfu is licensed under CC BY-SA 2.0. Photo may have been modified, resized, or cropped from original.

Situated at a convenient location, this cozy pizzeria has gathered over 3,319 reviews on Yelp with an admirable average rating of 4 stars.

One impressed customer shared,

Hands down the best crust I have had in NYC. The pizza is delicious and the ambiance is fun with a casual and hip vibe great for friends and family m! Amazing drink and good selection of food and pizza with fast and friendly service as the cherry on top! … Recommend getting a reservation if you want to come. This place is popular but absolutely worth it!

Don’t miss out on your chance to experience Roberta’s when you’re in New York City, as it’s a must-try for all pizza connoisseurs.

17. Lombardi’s Pizza

Visiting New York City? Lombardi’s Pizza is a must-try! With over 6,619 reviews on TripAdvisor and an average 4.0 rating, it’s a beloved pizzeria. Located in the Nolita area, this Coal Oven Pizza joint was notably recognized by Zagat.

Lombardi's Pizza
Lombardi’s Pizza” by SimonDoggett is licensed under CC BY 2.0. Photo may have been modified, resized, or cropped from original.

Lombardi’s has been serving mouthwatering Neapolitan-style pies since 1905. As America’s first pizzeria, it’s a charming New York institution. One delighted customer exclaims,

I have absolutely nothing bad to say about Lombardi’s. Old school NY brick oven pizza (the OG from what I hear). Large, thin pizzas. I love the marinara with meatball.

There can be a wait but it’s well worth it.

So, next time you’re in the neighborhood, don’t hesitate to treat your taste buds to the delightful experience of a Lombardi’s pizza!

18. Olio e Più

Visiting Olio e Più in Greenwich Village will surely make your taste buds dance! Boasting an impressive 4.5-star rating from 5,193 Yelp reviews, this Italian trattoria is a must-try spot for pizza lovers.

Located at 3 Greenwich Ave, you’ll find yourself immersed in the vibrant energy of New York City. One happy customer called it “the best pizza [they’ve] had outside of Italy” in their 5-star review.

Don’t miss the chance to treat yourself to their mouthwatering pizza creations. Remember, life’s too short for average pizza, so add Olio e Più to your NYC pizza bucket list today!

19. Prince Street Pizza

Visiting New York City? Prince Street Pizza is a must-try. With over 5,000 Yelp reviews and an average rating of 4.3 stars, this Nolita hotspot is a fan favorite.

Located at 27 Prince St, they offer mouth-watering Sicilian-style pizza. Definitely consider trying their famed pepperoni slice.

One happy customer commented on the deliciousness of their pizza, saying it’s “very saucy” with a “thick base” and “flavorful” pepperoni. Satisfy your taste buds during your NYC adventure!

20. Grimaldi’s Pizzeria

Stepping into Grimaldi’s Pizzeria is like stepping into a slice of New York City history. This beloved spot, located under the Brooklyn Bridge, has an impressive 3.6-star rating on Yelp, earned from over 4,982 reviews.

Grimaldi's Pizzeria
Grimaldi’s Pizza” by Chun’s Pictures is licensed under CC BY 2.0. Photo may have been modified, resized, or cropped from original.

You’ll appreciate their traditional coal-fired, brick-oven pizza. With handmade mozzarella, fresh dough, and that secret recipe sauce, each slice seems to capture the essence of the city.

Just like this happy customer said,

The pizza here is delicious. I’m a Chicago native and have had my fair share of pizza. The pizza is made in the wood oven and each ingredient is perfectly portioned. There isn’t anything overpowering! The service was excellent, the staff was attentive and friendly. … The ambiance is nice, we were seated upstairs!

Their Brooklyn location at 1 Front St makes it an ideal spot for enjoying some delicious pizza after a scenic stroll over the iconic bridge.

21. Artichoke Basille’s Pizza

Visiting Artichoke Basille’s Pizza in New York is a must-try experience. Located in the vibrant East Village at 321 E 14th St, you are in for a delightful treat.

Artichoke Basille's Pizza
Artichoke Basille’s Pizza” by Unsound Media is licensed under CC BY 2.0. “Artichoke Basille’s Pizza” by Unsound Media is licensed under CC BY 2.0. Photo may have been modified, resized, or cropped from original.

With an average rating of 3.8 stars on Yelp and 4,216 reviews, they’ve continuously impressed their customers.

One review worth mentioning comes from a happy customer who loved the “out of this world” taste of the signature Artichoke slice. You’ll appreciate how their menu caters to diverse preferences, as their unique Artichoke Pizza has certainly gained a fan following.

Cherish the late-night dining scene, as the friendly ambiance at Artichoke Basille’s brings people together.

22. Scarr’s Pizza

At Scarr’s Pizza, you’ll find yourself in a vibrant and welcoming atmosphere. Located in New York, NY, this popular pizza joint boasts an impressive 3.9 Yelp rating with glowing 890 reviews from satisfied customers.

One Yelper, for instance, raves about the perfect balance between crispy and chewy crust that Scarr’s Pizza offers.

Take a chance and dive into their menu, from their flavorful plain slice to their innovative square slice and beyond.

23. Bleecker Street Pizza

Located in the West Village, Bleecker Street Pizza is a favorite among pizza lovers. With over 2,993 Yelp reviews and an impressive 4.2-star rating, this spot serves delicious pizza that you won’t want to miss!

Bleecker Street Pizza
Bleecker Street Pizza” by VoxLive is licensed under CC BY 2.0. Photo may have been modified, resized, or cropped from original.

Their award-winning thin crust pizza has unbeatable flavors and their Nona Marie Pie is known as the best-seller. Patrons often praise their fresh ingredients and mouth-watering taste.

One satisfied customer shares,

Pizza was great, staff was super friendly especially Greg. Best sauce and dough I’ve had while in New York.

So, if you’re craving some amazing pizza, head to Bleecker Street Pizza and let your taste buds thank you!

24. NY Pizza Suprema

Looking for an amazing pizza experience in NYC? Let me introduce you to NY Pizza Suprema, a family-owned pizzeria since 1964.

NY Pizza Suprema
ny pizza suprema (10)” by Jeffrey Tastes is licensed under CC BY-SA 2.0. Photo may have been modified, resized, or cropped from original.

With an incredible history, this pizza joint is situated across from Penn Station and Madison Square Garden, making it perfect for on-the-go bites or sit-down meals.

With 2,578 Yelp reviews and a 4.3-star average rating, you can be sure that NY Pizza Suprema is a must-try spot for all pizza lovers. One Yelp reviewer even says,

There are so many options for New York Pizza, and this was my favorite of the ones we tried. The food was so good, and I appreciated having multiple vegan and vegetarian options. … The decor was straight out of the 1970s, which is my favorite. This tourist left happy!

You’ll never be disappointed, especially knowing that the Slice Harvester awarded this spot with a perfect score.

25. Lil Frankie’s

Located in New York’s Lower East Side, Lil Frankie’s is a popular spot for pizza lovers. With 1,520 Yelp reviews, it maintains an impressive average rating of 3.9. You’ll find Lil Frankie’s at 19 1st Avenue, New York, NY.

Lil Frankie's
lil frankies (2)” by Jeffrey Tastes is licensed under CC BY-SA 2.0. “lil frankies (2)” by Jeffrey Tastes is licensed under CC BY-SA 2.0.

Customers rave about their Neapolitan pizzas, delicious pastas, and an array of well-executed vegetable dishes. In this review, one happy customer shared just how much they enjoyed their visit to Lil Frankie’s.

In a cozy, lively atmosphere, you’ll relish every bite of your pizza, making your experience at Lil Frankie’s truly delightful.

26. Adrienne’s Pizzabar

Nestled in the historic West Village, you’ll find the popular Adrienne’s Pizzabar with an impressive 3.9 rating from 1,856 Yelp reviews.

Adrienne's Pizzabar
NYC Pizza Expedition 2009 stop #2” by jasoneppink is licensed under CC BY 2.0. Photo may have been modified, resized, or cropped from original.

Located at 54 Stone Street, New York, NY 10004, this pizzeria delights customers with its scrumptious pizza offerings and cozy atmosphere.

One customer described their experience here:

I’ve always heard good things about Adriennes but had never been until this week. The pizza was better than I expected, as was my Lavender Martini. I’d say my favorite slice was the Barese or the Pepperoni (the small peps that get really crispy edges are the best!).

For someone looking for pizza with a bit of a thicker crust in the area, I’d recommend Adriennes.

In addition to delicious pizza, you’ll also appreciate Adrienne’s Pizzabar for its outdoor seating, delivery, and takeout options.

With rave reviews and a friendly atmosphere, it’s no surprise that this pizzeria has become a favorite among New Yorkers.

27. Gelso & Grand

Welcome to Gelso & Grand, a delightful pizza destination in the heart of Little Italy.

With a remarkable 4.3-star rating earned from over 1,483 reviews on Yelp, this spot has put itself on the pizza map within the vibrant NYC culinary scene.

Located at the iconic corner of Mulberry & Grand Street, Gelso & Grand boasts an inviting atmosphere, where modern and classic New York dining are playfully intertwined. It’s a truly unforgettable experience for any pizza enthusiast!

One satisfied customer exclaimed: “The best pizza I’ve ever had! The crust was crispy on the outside, soft and doughy on the inside. The toppings were fresh and full of flavor.” So next time you’re craving a slice, remember that Gelso & Grand awaits your visit!

28. Totonno’s

Located in New York, NY, Totonno’s has been serving amazing pizza since 1924. This family-owned pizzeria has a whopping 842 Yelp reviews and an outstanding average rating of 3.9 stars.

Totonno's
totonnos (2)” by Jeffrey Tastes is licensed under CC BY-SA 2.0. Photo may have been modified, resized, or cropped from original.

One Yelper, in their glowing review, mentioned:

Solid pizza with a legendary reputation. It was not open inside so I just ordered takeout. They looked closed but you can order and pick it up. The pizza is very good and the crust is perfectly crunchy and chewy. It didn’t have that coal fired look or taste that I remember from years ago but it was still good. Hope this place stays around forever!

At Totonno’s, you know you’re in good hands.

29. Patsy’s Pizzeria

Established in 1933, Patsy’s Pizzeria introduced a delectable thin-crust style pizza to New Yorkers that swiftly gained popularity among East Coast residents.

With multiple locations, you can find one of their branches at 2287 1st Ave, New York, NY 10035.

Their eye-catching pizza has earned them an extraordinary number of reviews on Yelp, boasting a heartwarming 3.9-star average rating out of 952 reviews.

A satisfied customer, shared her delightful experience at Patsy’s in this review,

The best place to find OG thin crust cheese PIZZA. This is where you can find thin crust, perfectly charred, amazing cheese slice in NYC. If you’re in Harlem you gotta give this place a try. There is always a line for take out but the servers move fast.

There is seating inside the restaurant but nobody has got time for that. One pie runs about $18 but you don’t want this to go because this tastes the best right out of the oven.

Take your taste buds on a culinary adventure and treat yourself to a mouthwatering experience at Patsy’s Pizzeria.

30. Razza

Razza is a popular pizza place in New York City, and it has received numerous rave reviews. They currently have an impressive average rating of 4.2 stars on Yelp based on over 1,304 reviews.

Located in New York, it’s a perfect spot to satisfy your pizza cravings.

Their tasty and unique pizza toppings draw many people. One delighted customer shared their experience saying,

I can see why all the hype. Everything was cooked to perfection. The crust on the pizza was perfectly light and crispy yet soft. The meatballs were hearty and saucey and delicious. Salad had just the right amount of dressing.

You’ll surely enjoy their delicious, wood-fired creations.

30 Best Pizza Places in NYC: Key Takeaways

New York City is home to a plethora of delicious and unique pizza places.

Narrowing down the list to the 30 best pizza places can be a formidable task, but we’ve got you covered!

Prepare your taste buds for an adventure as you explore NYC’s finest pizza joints. From the long-standing Di Fara Pizza in Midwood to Juliana’s Pizza in Dumbo, you’ll be delighted by the variety of flavors and styles these pizzerias have to offer.

And finally, remember: you can never have enough pizza. So keep exploring, and let your cravings guide you to the best pizza places in NYC!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *